Replies to This Forum

Permalink Reply by Hitendrasinh Trikamsinh Desai on September 25, 2012 at 18:44

you are right i  use wrong  word i want to say  that as per ugc    SC, ST Teacher  with  55%  is clear the net and become teacher  but same % open category student want more 10 % i want to pin point this ugc criteria in my language. I personally believe that teaching skill is god gift less % student may be good teacher and higher % student may not be good teacher.

Thanks you for   agree with me that UGC Criteria for Qualifying UGC/NET Exam at different levels  is wrong     

Thanks for offering me  notes, Books for preparation of next net Exam
  hitendrasinh desai

     

Permalink Reply by Ashok Bhatt on September 25, 2012 at 5:50

Today's  World's Greatest Personalities are on Peak Due to There Talent not due to their Religion, Race and Sex. 

Permalink Reply by Bichitra Narzary on September 25, 2012 at 6:40

I also agree with Digambar Sir's comments. Jo Sc/ST/OBC ka laddu kaya wohi jane uska swad kaisa hai.....???.very bitter, evry second strugling in all rounds.

Permalink Reply by Dr. Ghante Pradipkumar on September 25, 2012 at 17:44

 R/ Sir, Hitendrasinh Trikamsinh Desai

 If you have any problem against UGC qualifying criteria i personally suggest you, COURTS  DOORS ARE OPEN FOR EVERYONE go there and  fight with Govt.

First of all accept that you fail in NET exam , if you have ability to clear the same apply again and clear the same . Do not blame on SC/ST/ OBC or ugc criteria . This is criteria and you (all ) should clear the same. I request you do not wast your energy to put like this statement. Prepare NET Exam .  We are teacher we should think broad .Our Best wishes always with you . 

Ghante P.B. 

Permalink Reply by Manmeet Kaur on September 25, 2012 at 17:56

I also agreed with no reservation criteria should be follow in UGC n other system

but it is going on from many years.............so it cant be changed now

but one more thing to say against reservation is "Is there mental level or knowledge is less than General category"???

So what is the difference between all?

Permalink Reply by Digambar Bhaurao Waghmare on September 25, 2012 at 18:52

Thanks madam \
I agree with you
I think reservation policy only used for voting bank
actual there is no need to reservation policy but
everyone get respect & should admit of Social, Economical , Education status of Backward caste person
All INDIANS ARE SOCIALLY EQUAL

Thanks & Regards
Digambar B Waghmare

Permalink Reply by Puja Singh on September 25, 2012 at 20:03

Mr. Desai

I also agree with you. You are right. UGC should be have similar criteria of qualify for all categories. UGC is not fair  with this issue.

Permalink Reply by Subhash Khode on September 25, 2012 at 20:21

Dear sir,

You are right at your side but there is no meaning for your this discussion because it is politics of our

great leader for vote. I am giving one real cases of my  friend:

1. One of the my friend working in reputed engineering institution of MP as LDC(Library) since last 14

years with M.Lib. qualification. Since he has 14 years experience in the field he has knowledge more

than newly appointed librarian. Two persons appointed in library as trainee  and they are learning and working under my friend. After one year Institute advertised various post including UDC post (for SC) in library as and one of the trainee appointed as UDC in library and now my friend has to work under him as per instruction of management. Think about the metal situation of my friend. 

2. I always found when i was student , after getting scholarship money , students planning to purchase something and party.

3. We could not change our poor image and salary system as librarian they how can we change national reservation system so do not think about this and prepare for next exam.

Permalink Reply by Sanjeev Dhurwey on September 25, 2012 at 20:26

Correct, it is absolutely engenendered by Politicians. We know everything, we cannot eliminate, we know who has done, we cannot point out. Let's stop this discussion, why to sensitise the issue unnecessarily when we know we cannot achieve anything out of it.

 

Permalink Reply by Anasua Ghosh on September 25, 2012 at 20:44

I totally agree with Mr. Siddhartha Shankar Ray....Merit needs to be the prime yardstick in any selection. Reserving seats and jobs for persons who have obtained all resources freely, but who still lag behind in competition is definitely affecting merit and is making the education system and our nation hollow from inside.

        The founding fathers of our nation wanted to uplift the downtrodden and bring them into the national mainstream. Therefore, they provided reservations in jobs for persons belonging to such communities, so that their disadvantage may be compensated. While it is true that 50 years ago, almost all the families in these communities were backward or downtrodden, it is also true that presently, backwardness and poverty are not restricted to only these communities. While it is true that many persons belonging to the backward communities have progressed, it is questionable whether their progress can be attributed solely to the advantage obtained through reservations? It is more likely that such affluent families belonging to backward communities have progressed owing to hard work and disciplined lifestyles.

             SC/ST/OBC people should work hard and compete with all in all exams, instead of crying for pity of reservation. If any reservation should be there in our country, it should be on the basis of financial condition of a family. Poor families whether SC/ST/OBC/General should be provided with free knowledge and resources. Lack of finance and resources should not deter intelligent and hardworking persons from working their way up the ladder.

                                     Not only UGC  but our country itself is following a wrong path for many many years which seems to be incurable. Really UGC/ NET has demoralised many efficient aspirants........

Permalink Reply by Anasua Ghosh on September 25, 2012 at 20:49

I totally agree with Mr. Siddhartha Shankar Ray....Merit needs to be the prime yardstick in any selection. Reserving seats and jobs for persons who have obtained all resources freely, but who still lag behind in competition is definitely affecting merit and is making the education system and our nation hollow from inside.

        The founding fathers of our nation wanted to uplift the downtrodden and bring them into the national mainstream. Therefore, they provided reservations in jobs for persons belonging to such communities, so that their disadvantage may be compensated. While it is true that 50 years ago, almost all the families in these communities were backward or downtrodden, it is also true that presently, backwardness and poverty are not restricted to only these communities. While it is true that many persons belonging to the backward communities have progressed, it is questionable whether their progress can be attributed solely to the advantage obtained through reservations? It is more likely that such affluent families belonging to backward communities have progressed owing to hard work and disciplined lifestyles.

             SC/ST/OBC people should work hard and compete with all in all exams, instead of crying for pity of reservation. If any reservation should be there in our country, it should be on the basis of financial condition of a family. Poor families whether SC/ST/OBC/General should be provided with free knowledge and resources. Lack of finance and resources should not deter intelligent and hardworking persons from working their way up the ladder.

                                     Not only UGC has done wrong by including "Reservation System" but our country itself is following a wrong path for many many years and which seems to be incurable. Really UGC/ NET has demoralised many efficient candidates........

Permalink Reply by thirupathi jayasri reddy on September 26, 2012 at 6:30

sir, well explained. ugc must react on this or those effected must move the legal action.

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• …
• 4
• 5
• 6
• 7
• 8
• Next ›
• Page