Replies to This Forum

Permalink Reply by Dr. Badan Barman on August 15, 2014 at 0:07

I personally dont know Dr. Gopakumar V.. But after going through your documents here are my observations-

1. Dr. Gopakumar V. got his Ph.D. in the year 2008 and UGC Ph.D. regulation 2009 came into effect from 1st June, 2009.

2. Dr. Gopakumar B got the UGC Scale on 1/6/1999, and UGC Rules for minimum qualification and eligibility criteria came into force from the year 2010.

Kindly note that both the above UGC circulars cannot be applied for retrospective dates.

Permalink Reply by Dr A Vijayakumar on August 15, 2014 at 4:44

All your findings are correct and UGC doesnot given any order that a Librarian who appoint as a University Librarian with 18 years experience with UGC Scale. If it is applicable no librarian can apply this post

Permalink Reply by Mayank Amonkar on August 19, 2014 at 19:07

Please read the matter carefully.

It is clearly mention in the UGC Rules for minimum qualification and eligibility criteria came into force form Vth and VIth pay commission says that minimum experience for University Librarian with 18 years experience with UGC status and it is accepted by all UGC affiliated Universities and systematic appointments are carried on in all other Universities.

Permalink Reply by Mayank Amonkar on August 20, 2014 at 0:07

@Badan Barman

As per your observation No. 1 -  Dr. Gopakumar V. got his Ph. D. in the year 2008 but Mangalore University awarder of doctorate clearly said in his RTI that his doctorate is not valid for any academic purpose including librarian of University as per UGC Regulation 2009. For detail please see Annexure IV.

As per your observation No. 2 -  Dr. Gopakumar V. granted only UGC Scale for monitory benefits within Kerala in the year 1999  but not UGC Status for Librarian  at all India level.  Please see Annexure II and attachment of Mohamed sager T. K.

Another thing is you  have  missed  is that he has  cleared  his M.LIB SC in the year 2004 and joined Goa university as a University Librarian in the year 2010 without UGC Status. As it is clearly mentioned in the circular attached byMohamed sager T. K.,  that Gopakumar was given only UGC scale and not UGC status.

Permalink Reply by Dr Intekhab Alam Siddiqui on August 15, 2014 at 19:36

Dear Sir,

1. As per the UGC Regulation 2010 for University Librarian, Ph.D. is desirable only.

2. Please specify, what was the valid qualification for the post of College Librarian in 1989 as per UGC Norms.

3. If he is not qualified for the post of University Librarian, then he was also not qualified the post of college librarian? what is your opinion? How the Govt. college appointed him without full qualification applicable at that time?

4. When the NET in Library Science started? and if joined as a college librarian before starting NET in Library Science, then he is exempted for ever.

Permalink Reply by Mohamed Sageer T. K. on August 18, 2014 at 18:48

Hi

I think in every states there are college librarians both UGC and Non-UGC (in different grades). In Kerala almost all the first grade college libraries have fully qualified UGC librarians. But there are a large number of Colleges lacks  College Librarians as prescribed by the UGC. Taking into acount the situation in college libraries in 2008 the Govt.of Kerala  introduced UGC scale in College libraries as a super numerary post relaxing the UGC qualification but the Govt. categorically cleared that it is the UGC sclae only and no other  benefit will be granted under a UGC Scheme. As we know UGC scale and UGC scheme are different. The UGC propose UGC scheme on the basis of certain qualification all over India. Those person who benefited the relaxation of UGC qualification in the state of Kerala as per the order cited above cannot claim for any UGC posts.  Further the UGC very clearly devised the qualifications for College Librarian/ Assistat University Librarian, Deputy Librarian and University Librarian. The there is no question arises that who should be a College Librarian and who should be a University Librarian.

Mohamed Sageer. T.K.

 

Attachments:

• g.o 50.pdf, 1.7 MB

Permalink Reply by Mayank Amonkar on August 20, 2014 at 0:11

@ Intekhab Alam Siddiqui

As you mentioned you have got it right he is noteven  eligible to become  college librarian,  forget university librarian

As per your observation No.2 the valid qualification for the post of College Librarian in 1989 as per UGC Norms is M.LIB. with 55% and Net passed. Where as Gopakumar V. is appointed as a common pool librarian with B.LIB., B.sc. for Kerala state.

As per your observation No.3 -  Dr. Gopakumar V. is  appointed as librarian grade I under the COMMON POOL  of librarians for Kerala state only but not as per UGC regulation or UGC librarian at all India level. Please see attachment Annexure I and till date he has never given UGG status by Kerala Government.

As per your observation No. 4 -  Dr. Gopakumar V. join the  library service in Kerala state as a COMMON POOL Librarian in the year  1989 with qualification B.sc., B.Lib.  and how come it is possible that B.lib. Sc. Can appear for NET/SET . where as he has completed his M.Lib. Sc. In the year 2004 and completed his Doctorate in the year 2008,

Join Goa University as a UGC University Librarian without UGC status in the year 2010 (Interview was held in the year 2009)

NET started in the year 1988 and minimum requirement for the NET examination in the year 1988 till date is M.Lib with 55% .

Attachments:

• annx12.pdf, 875 KB

Permalink Reply by Dr Intekhab Alam Siddiqui on August 20, 2014 at 17:22

Permalink Reply by MANOHARAN PILLAI.P.M on August 19, 2014 at 21:06

Sir,

I know Dr. Gopakumar V is qualified for the post. 

Permalink Reply by Mayank Amonkar on August 19, 2014 at 21:42

please read properly. don't make childish remarks. all the documents (evidences) are given.

i think you are also riding in same boat.

Permalink Reply by Dr Intekhab Alam Siddiqui on August 20, 2014 at 17:23

-         Sir, your efforts to collect the information under RTI are laudable and our views on the matter are personal. Ultimately you have to go to the High Court for final decision.

-         The Guidelines framed by the UGC are not applicable to States unless approved by the State Government.

-         In Maharashtra, MLib or NET/ SET was not compulsory for college librarians before Sept. 1991.

Permalink Reply by Nisha Mohan on August 22, 2014 at 0:42

Dear Mayank Please see my attachment for your detail

Dear Mayank Amonkar,

1. From last five days I have accesed  your  attached documents with letter of complain thouraly in detail and accordingly I have gone through all the Kerala Government circulars and UGC Circulars (through       I-net from 1986 till date)  which are quoted in complain letter. You are Highly appriciated for collecting this wonderfull laurel truthfull information.
2. As per UGC rules for college librarian recruitment in the year 1986 (Circular aquire through I-net) is M. Lib. Sc. with 55% whereas Gopakumar is appointed in the year 1989 with B.Sc., B.Lib. Sc. as a COMMON POOL librarian for kerala state Libraries.
3. As per my knowlege Experience Certificate (19 years and 05 months as a UGC college Librarian)  Submitted by Gopakumar is completely fake and froud, Gopakumar worked in five colleges form 1989 to 2009 and  at finale stage,  he worked  09 month in 5th College that is University college palayam and same collge is issuing Certificate for all other colleges, it is completely wrong.
4. As per HIGHER EDUCATION (A) DEPARTMENT G.O. (P) NO. 396/2010H. Edn dated Thiruvananthpuram: 17/12/2010 Read:- G.O. (Rt.) No.15/2009/H.Edn. dated 2.01.2009 (Order Names serial No. 39 as indicated in the circular) Dr. V. Gopakumar advised by PSC vide RAC (3) 4643/87GW dated 02/08/1989 and granted UGC scheme w.e.f. 1.6.1999 (on the basis of B.sc., B.Lib.sc.) as per G.O. (MS) No. 130/2000/H.Edn dated 11.8.2000 and was relieved from COMMON POOL on appointment as a University Librarian. Goa University as per G/O.(Rt)103/2010/H.Edn dated 13.01.2010. (Circular available on I-Net)
5. This above circular and circular attched by Mohamad Sageer T.K. clears that Gopakuamar has given UGC scheme in the year 1999 for monitary benefits but not UGC Status at all India UGC level and he relieved from common pool after selection as a Librarian In Goa University. (Releived on 13.01.2010).
6. According to the SUPREME COURT instruction to UGC and all UGC affiliated Universities and colleges that at the day of Interview (for work in Interview) or last day of submission of application, application should be with full demanded valied qualification and no further documents should accepted from any candidate.
7. Whereas on the day of Interview Gopakumar is entertained (and selected as University Librarian) by Goa University as Dr. Gopakumar without PH. D. and without required qualification, experience and publication with fake and froud certifiacte. It is wonderful Understanding between Goa University and Gopakumar.
8. SUGGESTION:  After going through all documents and with my 32 years experience as reputed institution Librarian with GOD FEAR I am saying that Gopakumar is 100% wrong and selected through froud and fake documents; therefore I am suggesting that , Please file IMMEDIATELY F.I.R. AT CLOSEST POLICE STATION against Dr. Gopakumar, V. and Principal, University College, Palayam. After that immediatly go to Goa High court, 101% you will get success and culprit will punished and fine. (PLEASE NOTE THAT IN THIS REGARDS ALL RELATED CIRCULARS ARE FREELY AVAILABLE ON SITE OF  HIGHER EDUCATION (A) DEPARTMENT, KERALA)

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• 2
• Next ›
• Page