"What are you up to?"
LIS Links
First and Largest Academic Social Network of LIS Professionals in India
LIS Links Becoming More Social
Birthdays
Birthdays Today
Latest Activity
"Dear All Librarian,
PFA
Call for Book Chapters/Research Papers for Edited Book To be Published with ISBN under IIP International Publi"
"What are you upCall for Chapters
Transforming Libraries in the Age of AI: Towards a Smarter
Knowledge Ecosystem to?"
7 Days Faculty Development Programme (FDP) on AI IN EDUCATION AND RESEARCH at Assam
October 9, 2026 at 6pm to October 15, 2026 at 7pm
Two-Day Online National Workshop on "Library Automation Using Koha" at Online
October 2, 2026 at 11am to October 3, 2026 at 5pm
National Conference on “Intelligent and Smart Digital Library (ISDL-2026)” at IIT Kharagpur at IIT Kharagpur
December 21, 2026 at 9am to December 22, 2026 at 6pm
6th LISACON 2026 at Bangalore. India
November 12, 2026 at 9am to November 14, 2026 at 5pm
Two-Day Online National Workshop on Library Automation Using Koha at Cooch Behar, West Bengal
October 2, 2026 at 11am to October 3, 2026 at 5pm
Is There Any Grammatical Mistake in Dr. Ranganatha's Five Law of Library Science
Many Lecturer says that there are grammatical mistake in the 2nd & 3rd Law of Library Science..
Every Reader his/her Book
Every Book It's Reader
The above statement doesn't make any sense. Please guide me, Is this really so and How Dr. Ranganathan can do such mistake
Views: 844
Replies to This Forum
-
Permalink Reply by Siddu on
-
Dear Atul
If you or your lecturers feel there is a grammatical mistake in the above laws enunciated by Dr. SRR then what according to you or your lecturers should be the right version?
If we know that then we will be able to debate freely on the issue.
I feel the laws stated above are right. Superfluous words have been eliminated and law of parsimony,I guess, has been applied.
-
Permalink Reply by Atul R. Sidurkar on
-
Thanku so much for your Reply...
Lecturer says that
3rd & 4th law should be
Every Reader has his /her Book
Every book has its Reader.
I toldthem that it is law and law should be free of grammar and unwanted word
-
Permalink Reply by Jignesh C. Parmar on
-
Dear sir,
Dr. Rangnathan is considered to be the father of library science, documentation, and information science in India. So we should understand that father can't make mistakes, instead children sometimes misinterpret the father.
One can say there are grammatical mistakes, If you write these laws without commas,
2nd law:- "Every reader his [or her] book."
3rd law:- "Every book its reader."
You may find it perfectly fine if they are written with commas;
2nd law:- "Every reader , his [or her] book."
3rd law:- "Every book , its reader."
There is no need to use any prepositions or verbs in this laws for grammatical corrections. It is worth to understand the meaning of these laws instead of criticizing Dr. Rangnathan.
Regards
© 2026 Created by Dr. Badan Barman.
Powered by
